The chatter about Sidney Crosby heading to the Colorado Avalanche is about as cliché as anything we’ve heard over the last few years.
But this time it could actually be different. Crosby is once again in the final year of his current deal, the Pittsburgh Penguins are likely hurtling towards a rebuild, and Nathan MacKinnon is out long term.
If that isn’t a perfect storm, I don’t know what is.
The issue here seems to be Crosby’s willingness to leave. As Penguins GM Kyle Dubas made clear, the organization will respect whatever their captain decides. And if he says, “I want to play with MacKinnon in Colorado,” that’s what will happen.
In fact, if Crosby is serious about it, he may just strong-arm Dubas into making the deal happen regardless of the cost to the organization.
The Avalanche, of course, will have to pay something up. Still, it would be really interesting to see if such a scenario could truly unfold.
There are some considerations to keep in mind. In the short term, nonetheless, this deal may actually have some legs.
Nathan MacKinnon’s long-term injury could create some cap space
If this situation had happened under the previous rules, I would say: Shut down MacKinnon for the rest of the regular season, put his $12.6 million cap hit on LTIR and get Crosby. Then, activate MacKinnon for the playoffs, and that’s that.
Because the Tampa Bay Lightning and the Vegas Golden Knights abused that system, the NHL closed the infamous “LTIR loophole.”
Now, if the Avalanche were to place MacKinnon on LTIR, the Avs would only get about $3.9 million in cap relief. The only way the Avs could get the full cap relief is by placing MacKinnon on season-ending LTIR. That move, unfortunately, would make him ineligible for the playoffs.
That’s why, if the Avs and Crosby are serious about one another, all sides will have to get creative about making the cap situation work.
Ultimately, if Crosby really wanted to become an Avalanche, at least for the rest of this season, the Penguins would have to accommodate his request by being as amenable as they could.
As for who Colorado would give up in such a trade, you would have to think that it would be a prospect-heavy package. The Avs do have some rising stars to move.
Since this is just a thought experiment, it’s likely that nothing really happens. But don’t be surprised if talk surrounding Crosby and the Avalanche picks up, even if there’s nothing credible to back it up.
