Colorado Avalanche Could Trade Tyson Barrie to the New Jersey Devils

The Colorado Avalanche could improve their team by trading defenseman Tyson Barrie to the New Jersey Devils for one of their young centers.

In the Colorado Avalanche offseason, one of the ways we entertain ourselves is by discussing trade possibilities. Center Matt Duchene is the favored trade bait, but conversations often turn to defenseman Tyson Barrie.

The rationale for trading Barrie is somewhat obvious — he’s one of our few prized possessions, meaning he has actual trade value. Indeed, a lot of teams have expressed interest in our young rover.

Recently Pucks and Pitchforks mentioned wanting Tyson Barrie for the New Jersey Devils. When I asked what they wanted for a “young, speedy, clutch, puck-moving defenseman,” they came up with the following:

So, let’s look at what Tyson Barrie brings to the table then consider the two young centers Pucks and Pitchforks mentioned.

Pros and Cons of Tyson Barrie’s Game

It’s true Colorado needs help on defense. However, it’s not like Barrie provides a lot of that. He can be a good puck mover, and he’s been known to be positionally sound, but defense is the first part of his game to disappear.

More from Mile High Sticking

• Could Colorado Avalanche move on from Pavel Francouz next offseason?
• 4 goalies to replace Pavel Francouz if he has to miss time
• Colorado Avalanche make sneaky signing with Tatar
• Colorado Avalanche captain Gabriel Landeskog could return in 2023-24 playoffs
• Colorado Avalanche rookie face-off tournament roster

No, Tyson Barrie’s great contribution to the team is his offense. Last season he led all defensemen and was fourth on the whole team for scoring with 38 points.

In four full seasons with the Colorado Avalanche, Barrie has twice reached 38 points, recorded 49 points, and had a 53-point season. Three times he’s scored over 10 goals.

As I noted above, Barrie is a strong skater, as shown by his roving ways. Not only can he score, he’s known to do so under pressure. If you’re down by one or two goals late in the third period, you want Tyson Barrie on the ice. He’s also the coveted right-hand defenseman.

Besides defense leaving his game, Barrie is undersized for an NHL defenseman at 5-foot-10, 190 pounds. It’s true he takes a hit like a champ, but it’s easy to overpower Barrie.

Nonetheless, Tyson Barrie is the new style of NHL defenseman — smallish, but speedy and able to move the puck. So, NHL teams want him. Let’s see what the New Jersey Devils might have on offer.

Pavel Zacha

Position: Center
Shoots: Left
Height: 6’3″
Weight: 210
Experience: 2 years (70 games)

The New Jersey Devils drafted center Pavel Zacha with the sixth-overall selection in 2015. Though I’m delighted with our pick, Mikko Rantanen, I wanted Zacha for the team at the time.

In his draft year, Chris Edwards from NHL Central Scouting described Zacha thus:

“He’s got high-end skill and is an excellent competitor. He plays an excellent two-way game. He’s physical and solid on his skates and can separate guys from the puck.”

His high-end offensive skill combined with his size and physicality is why I wanted Zacha for the Colorado Avalanche.

Two years on, Pavel Zacha has two years and 70 games under his belt. He hasn’t been a prolific scorer, recording eight goals and 16 assists for a total of 24 points. However, New Jersey hasn’t fully utilized him.

Right now the Hockey News is describing Zacha as a “naturally gifted offensive forward” who’s versatile to play center or wing. Indeed, the Hockey News posits that Zacha might not have the playmaking abilities to be a top-six center, so he might be better off as a winger.

That actually suits the Colorado Avalanche situation just fine. They already have a one-two punch with Nathan MacKinnon and Matt Duchene with center prospects in Tyson Jost and J.T. Compher.

While the Avs don’t favor big forwards as they once did, I doubt they’d be disappointed in Zacha’s bulk. It doesn’t slow him down, and it does allow him to play with something of a nasty streak — always helpful in the Central Division.

While Zacha isn’t anywhere near his potential, I don’t think he’s put up enough for Colorado to consider a one-for-one trade. I expect they’d want a draft pick or a prospect — or both. The New Jersey Devils stole our first-overall this year — they can give both for Tyson Barrie and, say, a later round pick.

So, here’s the trade:

Cheeky, I know. But I’m still steamed the Devils got that first-overall. I’m betting Avalanche GM Joe Sakic is, too.